Tried and Tested – Cupcake frostings
Cake Décor Two Colour Stripes Cupcake Frosting in Strawberry and Vanilla, 275g, £3.19 plus delivery.
Sugar, Glucose Syrup, Water, Palm Oil Fractions, Palm Oil, Rapeseed Oil, Maize Starch, Palm Kernel Oil, Anti-Caking Agent, Emulsifiers, Rice Starch, Maltodextrin, Strawberry Flavouring, Concentrates (Sweet Potato, Safflower, Apple), Salt, Preservative, Natural Bourbon Vanilla Extract, Citric Acid, Pectin, Sucrose, Lutein.
The attractive packaging and handy nozzle (contained in the lid) makes this look like a quality, user-friendly product, as does the promised two-tone swirl effect.
Testers found it quite tough to squeeze out of the tube to begin with, although this got easier with each cupcake. It was a bright ‘bubble gum’ pink colour (with a white stripe) and the consistency looked smooth, even and the swirl initially held its shape. The smell was more strawberry than vanilla.
Taste and texture
Despite initially holding its shape, it began to melt after ten minutes and after another ten minutes and it looked decidedly droopy. Upon tasting, first impressions were of a pleasant strawberry taste. However, there was a distinct aftertaste some testers didn’t like and most found subsequent bites too sweet and sickly.
Tesco Ready to Pipe Vanilla Flavoured Frosting, £2, 400g.
Sugar, Palm Oil, Water, Maltodextrin, Glucose Syrup, Dextrose, Fructose, Emulsifier, Salt, Acidity Regulator, Flavouring, Preservative, Beta-Carotene, Sugar, Tricalcium Phosphate, Salt, Sodium Ferrocyanide
This soft pouch is a good size and comes with three shaped nozzles to give three different piping effects, so is useful if you don’t have piping equipment at home.
A certain amount of strength was needed to extract the frosting, which, when it came out, was a pleasant cream colour. While it looked silky and smooth, it also looked quite thin, and like it might melt quickly.
Taste and texture
Sure enough, this frosting began to ‘wilt’ slightly after about 15 minutes, so frosted whirls looked a little soft. However, what it lacked in form, it made up for in its pleasant and ‘natural’ vanilla taste and smooth texture. Testers complimented it for its palatable flavour and lack of aftertaste.
Lakeland Sweet Treats
Frosting Duo in bubblegum and candyfloss
Sugar, Palm Oil, Humectant (Sorbitol), Water, Flavouring, Colour (Beetroot Red), Emulsifiers (Mono-and Diglycerides of Fatty Acids, Polysorbate 60), Preservative, (Potassium Sorbate), Acidity Regulator (Citric Acid).
Packaged in tubs rather than pouches, no sooner have you opened the lids than the sweet scent of each is immediately apparent. Each a different yet pleasing shade of pink, the texture appears thick and mousse-like.
Testers used a sandwich bag to pipe frostings. Piping consistency was excellent and held its form well. Combined with the pretty colours, testers all felt they looked very professional!
Taste and texture
Our testers were unanimous about the lovely light, airy texture that meant it wasn’t too heavy or ‘claggy’ like others tested. Each duo had a distinct and identifiable taste. The delicate taste of candyfloss was a clear winner as some found the bubblegum flavour a bit too sweet.
Betty Crocker Chocolate Fudge Icing 400g, £2.50. Tesco, Sainsburys.
Sugar, Water, Palm Oil, Fat-Reduced Cocoa Powder (8.5%), Invert Sugar Syrup, Emulsifiers: E471, E435, E481, Salt, Preservative: E202, Stabiliser: E450, Acidity Regulators: E330, E524
Packaged in a tub, this had a pleasant but not overpowering smell upon opening. It looked rich and very chocolatey with a dense texture.
Easy to scoop and pipe (again using a sandwich bag), if a little sticky! The icing flowed well from the bag. One expert tester found it worked better if beaten in a bowl beforehand for an even smoother look. We liked the fact unused frosting can be kept in the fridge for up to two weeks.
Sweet but with a nice, authentic chocolate taste. Our testers unanimously loved the texture and look of the cupcakes, which held their form well, describing them as luxurious and professional yet still with a home-made feel. The best tasting of all on test.